Start free trial
No credit card required
Is bank credit pulling back from commercial real estate?
Two questions, asked of two different instruments. The Federal Reserve's Senior Loan
Officer Opinion Survey asks banks what they are doing to their commercial real estate
lending standards — what they intend. The H.8 balance sheet
records what they actually hold. They are not the same question and they do not always
agree, which is the most useful thing about putting them next to each other. Beneath both sits
the acute tell: the Fed's emergency-funding facilities, which spike when banks are scrambling
for liquidity rather than deciding anything. National, and every series below is published by
the Fed — this page arranges them, it does not add to them.
CRE lending standards
-11.3net %
Banks easing · 2026Q3
CRE loan balances (H.8)
+3.5% YoY
$3.14T · Sep 2026
C&I standards (backdrop)
0.0net %
The general credit cycle · 2026Q3
Emergency funding, latest
$10.0B
Peak $152.9B · Mar 2023
Reading it
Banks are easing CRE lending standards (-11 net %, latest), and CRE balances are growing slowly (+3.5% YoY). Consistent with risk moving off bank books rather than with a clean recovery: a balance sheet can be held in place by selling as readily as by originating, and the survey asks about neither.
Net % of banks tightening CRE lending standards
1990Q3 → 2026Q3 · above zero = tightening
CRE lending standards
C&I standards (backdrop)
A net percent is the share of banks reporting tighter standards minus the share
reporting easier ones, so zero is neither and a negative reading means more banks easing than
tightening. Quarterly. Until 2013 the survey asked one combined commercial-real-estate
question; from 2013Q4 it asks three separate ones, and
the line continues on the closest of them — nonfarm nonresidential. That join is a change
of definition, not a revision, which is why it is marked on the chart rather than only
mentioned here. The commercial-and-industrial survey is drawn beside it because it is the same
question asked about ordinary business lending: when both move together the cause is the credit
cycle, and when only one moves the cause is the asset class.
Commercial-bank CRE loan balances, year-over-year %
Jun 2005 → Sep 2026 · what banks actually hold
Monthly, seasonally adjusted, all commercial banks. The twelve-month comparison is made
against the named prior month rather than twelve rows back, so a gap in the series
can never quietly turn the figure into a thirteen-month change. This is the half of the
question a survey cannot answer: a book can be held flat by selling loans just as easily as
by writing fewer, and only one of those is a decision a loan officer would report.
The Fed's emergency-funding facilities, $bn
Dec 2002 → now · not a decision — a scramble
Discount window
BTFP
Fed H.4.1: discount-window primary credit, and the Bank Term Funding Program that ran from
March 2023. The underlying series are weekly; this chart draws each calendar month's
highest weekly reading, because the whole content of the picture is the spike and a
monthly average would flatten March 2023 to a quarter of its size. The peak figures in the
tile above and the dates marked here are taken from the weekly series itself, untouched.
Nothing on this chart is a lending decision — it is the gauge that moves when a bank
needs cash this week, and the reason it belongs under the other two is that it is the one that
moves first.
What the series are
SLOOS = Fed Senior Loan Officer Opinion Survey, net % of banks tightening (quarterly). H.8 = Fed weekly/monthly bank balance sheet, CRE loans, SA. National series; 2013Q4 is a definitional break in the SLOOS CRE question.
Every figure on this page comes from the Federal Reserve and is free to look up: the survey is the SLOOS, the balance sheet is the H.8 release, the facilities are on the H.4.1. We have added the arrangement, the splice and the sentence at the top — nothing else.
What this page leaves out, and why
A page that omits something silently is indistinguishable from one that never had it, so this list is part of the page rather than a note about it. Two of these are decisions about what we are willing to publish; one is a limit of a chart with no controls on it, and will stop being true when somebody builds the thing that fixes it.
Recession bands and the CRE-distress rails beneath themdisclosure
Our charts elsewhere mark two things at once: when the economy was in recession, and — separately, derived from bank call reports — when commercial real estate itself was under stress. The gap between the two is the finding: CRE turns quarters after the economy does. This page does not read the series the second mark comes from, so it could only draw the recessions, which invites exactly the conclusion the pair exists to refuse. The Cycle Clock publishes both, and this page links to it.
How the Fed and the FSOC frame CRE in their own stability reportsdisclosure
We hold a reading of those reports: a score for how prominently commercial real estate featured, a direction, a characterization, the passages it came from. That is not a Federal Reserve series — it is our interpretation of somebody else's document, and publishing a number we assigned to a regulator's report, under our name, is grading rather than disclosing. Everything else on this page is a figure the Fed published and you can check.
The three CRE sub-questions: construction, nonfarm nonresidential, multifamilyrendering
These are public Federal Reserve series and there is no argument against publishing them. They are off this chart because the survey only split CRE into three in late 2013, so on an axis that opens in 1990 all three would occupy the right-hand third — and a line that starts two-thirds of the way along reads as a hole in the record rather than as a later question. The two series drawn here both run the whole span, so they can share one axis honestly.
Where this sits
This page is national, and it is what banks say alongside what their balance sheet shows. It is one hand of a clock with several.
National Pulse →
The written read on where U.S. commercial real estate credit is, published as the record moves.
Cycle Clock →
Where the cycle sits against 1991 to now, with the recession bands and the CRE-distress rails this page withholds.
Asset Dimension →
Which property types the distress is actually in. Credit supply is national; distress is not.
Methodology →
Where every number on this site comes from, and what each source does and does not cover.
See the whole picture, not just the backdrop.
These pages publish the national reads — where the credit cycle sits, whether banks are pulling back from commercial real estate, and what moved this week. The platform carries them down to the market and the loan: the policy frame, the index rates a mortgage prices over, and what any of it touches in the buildings you hold.