Start free trial
No credit card required
Commercial Real Estate Credit —
Buffalo-Cheektowaga, NY
The state of disclosed CRE credit in this market · NY
The read
$645M of CMBS across 31 loans. The heaviest maturity load lands in 2029 ($142M). Multifamily is the largest book ($118M, 0.0% distressed). 29 on-the-ground distress events in the past year (1,438 jobs).
Overview
CMBS
Submarkets
Local Banks
Jobs & Demand
On The Ground
Loading map…
The CMBS properties our stress model flags here, plus recent store closures and layoffs. Stressed is a wider net than distressed — the distressed figure above counts only loans already in special servicing or 60+ days delinquent, while these dots also include performing loans facing maturity or coverage pressure. Property dots sit at the center of their ZIP code, not the building — they show where stress concentrates, not which asset. Closures and layoffs are pinned to address where we have it. Open any dot to the building and the loan behind it →
Buffalo's CMBS Book Sits Quiet, but the Street-Level Record Is Loud
Buffalo-Cheektowaga carries $645M of CMBS across 31 loans, a modest book by national standards and one that, for now, shows no signs of strain in its securitized core. The heaviest maturity load does not land until 2029, when $142M comes due — the year that dominates the metro's refinancing calendar and the one credit desks should mark first.
Multifamily is the largest sector here at $118M, and it is clean: 0.0% distressed against a national multifamily rate of 7.9%. That gap is the headline number for the lending side of this market — the metro's biggest book is running well inside the national benchmark rather than tracking it.
The contrast is on the ground. The filed record logged 29 distress events over the past year — 17 store closures and 12 layoff notices totaling 1,438 jobs — a level of real-economy disruption that the loan tape does not yet reflect. Office-using employment of 97,251 is down 3.0% year over year, and unemployment sits at 4.5%, up 0.1 point. Among the three banks tracked locally, none are distressed, though two carry early-warning flags worth watching.
Written 2026-10-22
CMBS Distressed UPB
Not reported
fewer than 3 loans are distressed here, too few for the share to be a rate — the book size and loan count above are unaffected
CMBS Maturing ≤ 24mo
$74M
Banks HQ’d Here (stressed)
0 / 3
Bank Early-Warning
2 flagged
Store Closures (1y)
17
Layoff Notices (1y)
12 / 1,438 jobs
0.32% of metro employment
CMBS Loans / UPB
31 / $645M
Unemployment · Aug 2026
4.5%
+0.1pp yr
Office-Using Jobs · 2024
97,251
-3.0% yr
How much CRE distress is there in Buffalo-Cheektowaga, NY right now?
For Buffalo-Cheektowaga, NY, the distress picture is mixed. The strongest signals are in the employment-related legs: the closures leg is elevated with 16 closures (3.56 per 100k jobs, 30th of 392 by count), and the WARN leg is also elevated with 8 notices (0.21% of employment, 67th of 386 by count). However, the two capital-market legs read quiet: bank CRE over the noncurrent line sits at $52.6mm (0.39% rate, 219th of 393), and the securitized tape shows 3 special-servicing rows (1.83% of balance, 52nd of 335 — a floor). The four disagreeing pairs each show employment-related stress running ahead of lender balance sheets, with the dominant read being "tenants are leaving and no lender balance sheet shows it yet." Notably, the closures/WARN pair is an agree_hot signal — both elevated, consistent with a retail story. In sum, the metro shows operating-level distress (closures, layoffs) that has not yet translated into the bank or CMBS books.
The figures behind this answer
| Signal | Level | Rate | Rank by count | Rank by rate | Reading |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| store closures store closures per 100,000 jobs |
16 closures | 3.56 per 100k jobs | 30 of 392 | 66 of 392 | elevated trailing 365 days to today
|
| layoff notices (WARN) workers on layoff notices as a share of the metro's employment |
8 notices | 0.21% | 67 of 386 | 108 of 386 | elevated trailing 365 days to today
|
| bank CRE at lenders over the noncurrent line share of the CRE lent into this metro that sits at a lender over the blended-noncurrent line |
$52.6mm | 0.39% | 219 of 393 | 316 of 393 | quiet
allocated 2026-03-31
|
| securitized loans in special servicing share of the securitized balance read here that is in special servicing |
3 loan records | 1.83% | 52 of 335 | 95 of 335 | quiet
floor 2026-07-29
|
6 pairs compared
1 both elevated
1 both quiet
4 disagreeing
0 unreadable — a side is blind
2 of four legs elevated
one metro, four independent feeds, each on its own denominator
114 of 441 metros have at least one blind leg and 48 are blind on all four. Those 48 are the same metros the board's map cannot place and the metro resolver cannot name: one ZIP-to-CBSA crosswalk boundary, showing up three ways.
Elevation is computed on the COUNT, over a flat threshold, which is a size filter. New York is 2nd of 392 by store closures and 264th of the same 392 by closures per job — both true, and which one you lead with decides what the reader believes.
Where two legs disagree, that is usually a fact about WHICH mechanism is running, not an error in either feed and not a worse metro.
A leg with no denominator, or whose numerator cannot be measured, reads LOW and means nothing. Each leg publishes a measurement state (allocated, floor, measured, no denominator, no rate, not measurable) for that reason.
Store closures: divided by 449,249 jobs
— all metro jobs, QCEW annual average — a SIZE normaliser, not a matched population: the feed spans retail, food service and pharmacy and no single QCEW sector covers it. The MATCHED read sits beside it as this leg's second reading (trailing 365 days to today).
Layoff notices (WARN): divided by 542,629 employed
— employed persons, BLS LAUS, not seasonally adjusted (trailing 365 days to today).
Bank CRE at lenders over the noncurrent line: divided by $13,430.9 mm
— bank CRE allocated to this metro by branch deposits (2026-03-31).
Securitized loans in special servicing: divided by $712.0 mm
— current balance on the non-pari-passu rows of this tape — the trust's slice, not the whole loan, on both sides of the ratio (2026-07-29).
Written from the figures above · CBSA 15380 · stress_metro · last changed 28 Aug 2026
· Ask your own question →
Jobs & Demand — the labor market under the collateralWatch it change →
Every other zone on this page reads the credit — what the loan is doing.
This one reads the demand underneath it. Office jobs pay office rent;
office rent services the office loan. When the jobs go, the DSCR follows — but not for another year or two.
That lag is the whole point of looking here.
Unemployment · Aug 2026
4.5%
+0.1pp yr
Last 24 months
3.3%5.1%
Monthly metro unemployment (BLS LAUS) — the freshest labor signal there is,
about six weeks behind. Read the direction, not the level: a 4% metro that is rising and a 6% metro that is
falling are not telling you the same thing.
Jobs by CRE-relevant sector · 2024
Annual employment by sector (BLS QCEW, 2024; 449,249 jobs in the metro).
QCEW lags — it is the structural read, not the current one, and we pair it with the monthly unemployment above on purpose.
Office-using sums five supersectors; where BLS withholds any one of them for
disclosure, we show nothing rather than a number we know is too low — so a missing sector here means
“suppressed at the source,” not “zero.”
Sector Heat — CMBS distress rate by property type (metro vs national)See the loans behind the bar →
Fewer than 3 loans here are distressed, too few for a distress rate to mean anything — so there is no rate to test against this metro's property mix. 0 of 1 property types here run a higher distress rate than the national average for that type (the tick on each bar).
Maturity Wall — CMBS coming due by year, distress within eachSee what’s maturing →
$74M — 11% of the metro's balance — matures within two years; the red slice of each bar is already distressed.
Distress Trend — is this market turning?Track it quarter by quarter →
Too few loans here are distressed for a quarterly rate to be a rate, so no direction is stated. The quarters that can be read are shown below.
Same definition as the cards above — distressed means in special servicing or 60+ days delinquent, dollar-weighted — on a different clock. The cards are today’s tape; this is the disclosed history panel, quarter by quarter, so you can read direction rather than level. Trusts file monthly, so a quarter is usually well covered within weeks of opening and the newest one shown is normally the current one; it is withheld only when its filed book falls below 60% of recent quarters.
Share of the metro’s CMBS in special servicing or 60+ days delinquent, by quarter — a firmer, backward-looking read. A loan under 1.0x DSCR that is still paying is not counted here.
Submarket Heat — where in the metro the distress sitsOpen the submarket →
The top three submarkets hold $552M of the metro's $645M; each bar's colored share is its distress rate.
Bank Door — what the local bank sector could absorbSee it on every loan’s exit read →
$74M of CMBS matures here within two years.
The 10 regional and local banks that gather deposits here could write roughly
$876M more CRE before the 300% supervisory line, so the maturing balance is
0.08× that room.
The median metro sits at 0.13×.
Regional Bank Room
$876M
After Committed Draws
$751M / −14%
Maturing ÷ Room
0.08×
Banks In Footprint
10 / 3 at the line
The room above is already part-sold. Construction lending is a promise drawn
down over two or three years, and the undrawn part is an obligation the bank cannot decline while the borrower performs
— every one of those dollars lands in the same CRE book the 300% line governs. These banks
have $212M of construction committed and not yet
advanced, of which $125M
comes out of the room above, leaving $751M,
with 5 banks
whose entire remaining room is spoken for.
A bank with no room contributes zero here, never a negative one — capacity does not net
across balance sheets — so $87M of what has
been promised is not deducted at all, because there is nothing left to deduct it from. On today’s
capital that is funding already contracted which would cross the line as it draws.
SR 06-26 draws a second line at 100% of capital for construction and land:
4 more cross it
once their own commitments fund.
Counted — 10 regional & local CRE lenders
| Bank | Deposit share | CRE / Capital* | Room contributed | Noncurrent CRE |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Northwest Bank PA | 18.5% | 109% total 145%
|
🔒 | 1.53% |
| Alden State Bank NY | 100.0% | 161% total 183%
|
🔒 | 0.90% |
| Lake Shore Bank NY | 44.1% | 202% total 245%
|
🔒 | 0.03% |
| Cnb Bank PA | 14.1% | 269% total 341%
|
🔒 | 0.61% |
| Bank Of Holland NY | 100.0% | 156% total 211%
|
🔒 | 0.17% |
| Cattaraugus County Bank NY | 15.9% | 172% total 251%
|
🔒 | 1.79% |
| Five Star Bank NY | 7.6% | 294% total 342%
|
🔒 | 0.87% |
| Chemung Canal Trust Company NY | 4.1% | 375% total 428%
|
🔒 | 0.14% |
| Tompkins Community Bank NY | 1.5% | 323% total 392%
|
🔒 | 0.68% |
| Nextier Bank, National Association PA | 1.2% | 315% total 362%
|
🔒 | 2.69% |
Not counted — 10 banks with deposits here
These hold deposits in this metro but are left out of the capacity above, because for them deposit location stops indicating where they lend — or they do not lend CRE at all. Real money that could refinance here is deliberately not counted.
no CRE book — CRE under 100% of capital — not a CRE lender
Keybank National Association OH · Hsbc Bank Usa, National Association VA · Bank Of America, National Association NC · Citizens Bank, National Association RI · Jpmorgan Chase Bank, National Association OH · Wilmington Trust, National Association DE
national — operates in more than 5 states, so deposits stop indicating where it lends
Manufacturers And Traders Trust Company NY · Nbt Bank, National Association NY · Community Bank, National Association NY · Woodforest National Bank TX
* Two ratios, two perimeters.
The large figure is supervisory CRE over total risk-based capital —
construction, multifamily and non-owner-occupied nonfarm nonresidential. That is the book SR 06-26 draws its
300% line against, and it is what the red coloring and the room contributed are both measured on.
Total beneath it adds owner-occupied CRE — lending to a business on
its own premises — which the guidance deliberately leaves out. A bank can sit well above 300% on total CRE and
still be inside the line, with real room to lend; both are shown so the gap is visible rather than surprising.
How to read this. It is not whether any particular loan can refinance — a borrower also reaches
national banks, life companies, agencies and debt funds. It is how much of this metro’s maturing volume the local
bank sector could absorb if it were the only door.
Banks are placed by deposit share (FDIC Summary of Deposits, June 2026) — a proxy for
where they lend, not a measurement; call reports carry no collateral geography. Room = 3× total risk-based capital less CRE held
(SR 06-26, the capital base the rule names — not book equity), from Q2 2026 call reports, apportioned by that share.
Committed construction comes from FFIEC Schedule RC-L as filed at 2026-06-30 —
the undrawn half of loans already written, which the balance sheet above does not show.
Banks in more than 5 states, single-branch bookers and banks that do not lend CRE are excluded —
315 banks holding $263.8B of national capacity not counted here.
Local Lenders — banks headquartered here, worst CRE noncurrent firstUnlock each bank’s early-warning flag →
| Bank | Total CRE | CRE / Capital* | Noncurrent CRE | Early Warning |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Manufacturers And Traders Trust Company | $34.7B | 104% total 149%
|
1.06% | 🔒 |
| Bank Of Holland | $53M | 156% total 211%
|
0.17% | 🔒 |
| Alden State Bank | $133M | 161% total 183%
|
0.90% | 🔒 |
* Two ratios, two perimeters.
The large figure is supervisory CRE over total risk-based capital —
construction, multifamily and non-owner-occupied nonfarm nonresidential. That is the book SR 06-26 draws its
300% line against, and it is what the red coloring and the room contributed are both measured on.
Total beneath it adds owner-occupied CRE — lending to a business on
its own premises — which the guidance deliberately leaves out. A bank can sit well above 300% on total CRE and
still be inside the line, with real room to lend; both are shown so the gap is visible rather than surprising.
Banks are matched to their HQ metro (a proxy for footprint). Noncurrent CRE = CRE-balance-weighted blend of multifamily / nonresidential / construction noncurrent (distress already arrived). Early Warning is a validated leading signal — the bank’s 30-89 early-delinquency rank among all CRE lenders this quarter, which has predicted ~2.3× forward CRE distress. Per-bank flags are on a plan.
On The Ground — recent closures, layoffs & CRE bankruptciesTie these events to loans →
29 local distress events in the past year (1,438 jobs) — store closures, layoffs, and commercial real estate bankruptcies near this metro's collateral.
2026-10-23
BANKRUPTCY
Chapter 11
2026-10-23
BANKRUPTCY
Chapter 11
2026-10-22
BANKRUPTCY
Chapter 11
2026-10-22
BANKRUPTCY
Chapter 7
2026-10-21
BANKRUPTCY
Chapter 11
2026-10-16
BANKRUPTCY
Chapter 11
2026-10-16
BANKRUPTCY
Chapter 11
2026-10-15
BANKRUPTCY
Chapter 11
2026-10-05
CLOSURE
Buffalo
2026-10-02
LAYOFF
Niagara Falls
2026-10-02
LAYOFF
Niagara Falls
2026-10-01
CLOSURE
Niagara Falls
2026-09-09
LAYOFF
28 jobs · Erie
2026-08-25
CLOSURE
Williamsville
2026-08-12
CLOSURE
Amherst
What has actually happened on the ground in Buffalo-Cheektowaga, NY recently?
Over the trailing 365-day window, the Buffalo-Cheektowaga, NY metro shows 17 store closures and 12 WARN notices, with 1,438 jobs affected — a figure that should be read as a floor, since notices stating no headcount are counted but contribute zero jobs. On the capital side, the reading is 140 CRE-likely bankruptcies, but this is a STATE PROXY rather than a metro-native count: a court case counts in its filing district and an SEC 8-K in the filer's state, not where the property is, so the total reflects filings in the states this metro's collateral sits in, and because coverage widened to both court feeds on 2026-09-16, counts before and after that date are not comparable.
The figures behind this answer
- Store closures
- 17
- WARN layoff notices
- 12
- Jobs on those notices
- 1,438
- CRE-related bankruptcies
- 140
- Window, in days
- 365
STATE PROXY — a court case counts in its filing district and an SEC 8-K in the filer's state, not where the property is, so this counts CRE-likely filings in the states this metro's collateral sits in. It is not a metro-native count. Each court case is counted once even when both PACER and CourtListener carry it. A court case's state is its filing district; an SEC 8-K or news item carries the filer's state. Coverage widened to both court feeds on 2026-09-16, so counts before and after that date are not comparable.
affected_employees is nullable — notices that state no headcount are counted but contribute 0 jobs, so this is a floor.
Closures are matched ZIP -> CBSA and only APPROVED rows count (a pending, machine-extracted row is not yet a closure). This mirrors the Metro Pulse page, not the convergence board — the board applies neither filter and counts higher. Layoffs take the same ZIP -> CBSA and review treatment, and a WARN notice counts if it affects >= 10 people or does not state a headcount (a NULL is not 'fewer than 10').
Written from the figures above · CBSA 15380 · geo_events · last changed 25 Oct 2026
· Ask your own question →
What this page can’t do
Everything above is a snapshot — one market, as it stands today, and
it’s yours to read. What a snapshot can’t tell you is when it moves: which loan slipped a DSCR band
this month, which bank’s early-warning rank crossed into the top quartile, which submarket started turning
while the headline number still looked fine. Distress doesn’t announce itself on the day you happen to check.
This page
One metro · one moment · you come looking.
Verstavo
Every metro · every month · it comes looking for you.
CMBS covers the securitized slice of CRE; bank, closure and layoff signals widen the view.
“No data” in a zone means we don’t observe it here, not that there is no stress.
Employment is BLS (QCEW annual, LAUS monthly) — public data, and the demand leg under all of it.
See the whole picture, not just the pulse.
Metro Pulse is the free, public read — one page for every market we cover. The platform goes loan‑by‑loan inside it: which buildings carry the stress, when their debt comes due, and your own portfolio benchmarked against the market you are standing in.